Andy is privately instructed on behalf of J, a company director, who is accused of raping a female. The allegations of rape are vehemently denied. J accepts that sexual intercourse took place but that all activity was consensual.
The case raises several unusual features. Police initially took no further action against J, only for the complainant to appeal the decision under the victims right to review scheme and providing further evidence, including digital social media evidence. As a result of the further evidence the prosecution reversed their original decision, and our client was charged and now faces trial.
The defence have obtained expert evidence, including on the digital evidence, casting serious doubt upon the prosecution case, including the ‘new’ prosecution evidence that led to the reversal in charging decision. Just prior to the Trial starting the Prosecution finally indicated that the defence expert evidence was accepted and would not be challenged, changing the evidential picture considerably.
Additionally, following further disclosure requests made by the defence, more disclosure was obtained from the prosecution that suggests the original decision to take no further action was indeed the correct decision. The defence expert evidence obtained and the further disclosure from the prosecution supports the defence case and seriously undermines the case for the Crown.
As a result of the additional information, the defence immediately made further disclosure requests, submitted an application to stay the proceedings as an abuse of process and submitted extensive and detailed representations to the Prosecution as to why the evidential test is not met. As a result, the Trial date has been vacated whilst the Prosecution consider their position and whether they will accede to the defence submissions that no evidence should now be offered against J without a Trial taking place.
The case continues